Affiliate Disclosure: Whenever you click on hyperlinks at Solely Greats & make a purchase order, we might earn a fee. As a free website, we be part of associates like eBay & Amazon to assist offset our prices. THANK YOU in your help!
Final Up to date On: April 14th, 2025
The buying and selling card group isn’t any stranger to error playing cards, however a number of NSFW (not secure for work) playing cards stay in infamy for all of the unsuitable causes. This text will dive into among the most controversial error playing cards produced by corporations like Topps, Fleer, and Pokémon. I will even spotlight the backstory of every card’s manufacturing, present costs, and the quantity of PSA graded copies in existence.
Let’s get into it!
What are Error Playing cards?
An error card in sports activities collectibles is a buying and selling card that comprises an error or inaccuracy. A wide range of errors can present up on a card for it to be categorized as an error card. This could embody incorrect photographs, unsuitable statistics, misspellings, participant description errors, and plenty of different errors. In consequence, an error card turns into a uncommon variation of the initially designed card.
A number of the first error playing cards that baseball followers got here throughout date again to 1909 through the tobacco card period. Probably the most notable and coveted error card from that point is Sherry Magee’s T206 Piedmont card, which reveals his final identify misspelled.
Because the buying and selling card trade developed and the area of interest of error card amassing was shaped, corporations started to “mistakenly” produce error playing cards displaying specific phrases and pictures to seize the eye of collectors. The timing of those inappropriate misprints through the junk wax era sparked a stage of error card reputation the interest had by no means seen — beginning with essentially the most controversial baseball error card produced in 1989.
6 Most Controversial Error Playing cards
1989 Fleer #616 Billy Ripken FF Error Card
Billy Ripken’s 1989 Fleer #616 “FF” card is taken into account the king of error playing cards, because of the vulgar four-letter phrase printed on the knob of his bat and the unprecedented consideration it obtained upon launch. Fleer claimed the error card was “by chance” positioned in packs as a result of the editors didn’t spot the error throughout manufacturing. Because the interest started to find the infamous error card in 1989 Fleer packs, it provoked a craze of large demand from collectors, spending a whole bunch of {dollars} to acquire it. The mainstream information protection and outrage from dad and mom over its manufacturing compelled Fleer to shortly create quite a few edited variations with the profanity coated.
Billy Ripken declared that the curse phrase written on the bat was not by him, however by a teammate as a prank. However in 2009, the brother of Cal Ripken Jr. ultimately confessed that he was the one who wrote FF on the bat. Based on Ripken, he merely wrote the phrase on the knob as a solution to differentiate his batting apply from his recreation bats. He additionally acknowledged that it’s laborious to imagine Fleer didn’t purposely launch the error card as a publicity stunt. Nevertheless, Ripken has embraced the cardboard’s creation and its notorious legacy within the sports activities card interest.
Regardless of the error card’s excessive reputation, it’s not essentially thought-about uncommon. PSA has graded the long-lasting error card practically 20,000 instances with virtually 3,000 examples having obtained a Gem Mint 10 grade. As of this writing, PSA 10 gross sales are within the $650-$700 vary. Though Billy Ripken wasn’t an All-Star caliber participant, the fascinating story behind his 1989 Fleer FF error card has fueled its rising demand and worth over time — take into account that the cardboard was promoting for round $100 again in 2019!
1990 Pacific Senior League #126 Jim Nettles A**gap Error Card
Only one 12 months after Ripken’s FF error hit the interest, Jim Nettles’ 1990 Pacific Senior League error card turned the subsequent notorious bat knob card with some soiled language. This time, it dialed issues down from “f*ck face” to the marginally extra well mannered “a**gap.” On the time, Nettles — a former MLB outfielder — was taking part in within the Senior Skilled Baseball Affiliation, a winter league for gamers aged 35 and up primarily based in Florida.
The story behind the error card’s creation is just like Ripken’s FF card. Neither Nettles, the photographer, nor the editors at Pacific seen the candid phrase on the picture or card till it was too late. About 20 years following the a-hole error card’s manufacturing, Nettles claimed in an interview that the bat wasn’t his, however a teammate’s. The photographer requested that he take a photograph throughout a morning exercise and gave him the bat to pose with. The previous MLB outfielder acknowledged he’s not a fan of the cardboard and purposely indicators over the knob when collectors ask him to autograph it.
Uncooked copies of the notorious butthole error card will be discovered on eBay for as little as $10, whereas PSA 10s have offered for near $100. However have in mind—there’s an enormous distinction in what number of are on the market in comparison with Ripken’s card. Only 190 copies of the Nettles error card have been graded by PSA, with simply 47 incomes a Gem Mint 10.
1977 Topps Stars Wars #207 C-3PO D*ck Error Card
I’m unsure if d*ck pics existed within the Seventies, however Star Wars character C-3PO is proven packing an enormous boner on this obscene card featured within the film franchise’s 1977 Topps set. The origins of the error card’s picture and the way Topps may pull this off visually have been questioned for years — with a number of claims made by Star Wars, Topps, and even the actor who performed the character (Anthony Daniels).
The Star Wars official web site in 2007 acknowledged the “further appendage” was not edited into the cardboard and the photograph’s existence is a mixture of timing and lighting. An worker for Topps who managed the collection of card photographs on the time expressed that the X-rated picture was brought on by prankster prop masters messing round whereas engaged on the movie. Anthony Daniels deemed that each theories have been false and the uncovered photograph was a results of a dressing up malfunction throughout a scene the place C-3PO was dropped into an oil bathtub. The actor additionally acknowledged that he believes Topps enlarged and detailed the crotch space of the picture.
No matter which story is asserted the reality, Topps needed to shortly reissue the cardboard with the shaft airbrushed out of the photograph.
The C-3PO error card’s low amount in uncooked and PSA graded copies can’t be understated and is one other main promoting level to collectors. PSA has graded roughly 2,000 copies with solely 5 examples receiving the best grade. The final PSA 10 sale dates again to 2020, promoting on eBay for $4,999. The boner error card of the franchise’s beloved robotic is the holy grail of non-sports error playing cards and the second most infamous error card in your entire interest.
2013 Topps #71 Kyle Kendrick Crotch Shot Error Card
Persevering with with the theme of pelvic-related error playing cards, Topps mistakenly produced one other one in 2013 that includes Phillies participant Kyle Kendrick. The picture captures an excessive close-up of the pitcher from his chest to his knees and presents an epic crotch shot on the heart of the cardboard. Technically, there isn’t something lewd or inappropriate within the photograph chosen for the cardboard, however a picture formatting mishap from a Topps Designer was the primary purpose for its conception.
Topps fortunately found the screw-up early within the manufacturing course of and prevented any from getting into packs, however a small variety of them have been present in 2013 Topps sealed manufacturing unit units. In consequence, Kendrick’s SSP Topps #71 is difficult to acquire and is arguably the rarest error card on our record. From a gross sales quantity standpoint, the cardboard generates solely a few eBay transactions per 30 days. There are lower than 15 PSA graded copies and 10 copies in gem mint situation, with the newest uncooked gross sales between $50-$70.
1997 Pokémon Japanese Crew Rocket #88 Grimer Banned Card
I’d take into account sports activities playing cards to be the most well-liked style of disputable error playing cards to gather, however TCGs like Pokémon have additionally produced buying and selling playing cards with questionable pictures and imagery. The 1997 Pokémon Japanese Crew Rocket #88 Grimer card reveals the character creeping up a sewer trying beneath a girl’s skirt. However did the creator of the Grimer picture purposely have its eyes peeking up at her goodies? The designer has repeatedly denied that the artwork was created with any intention of depicting degrading habits.
After Pokémon producers realized the cardboard’s perverted “peeping tom” vibes, it was banned, and designers altered Grimer’s eyes to look straight forward for the English model set launch. Uncooked variations of the frequent Pokémon banned card are promoting for round $10 with a number of eBay transactions per week. PSA 10 copies of the cardboard (pop 688) are fetching north of $200.
2014 Topps UFC Ronda Rousey 1st in her Class Patch
I wouldn’t essentially categorize Ronda Rousey’s 2014 Topps UFC Knockouts 1st In Her Class Patch Auto as an error card, however I extremely doubt Topps meant for such a naughty phrase throughout the lettering of the identify to be the primary takeaway by collectors. To not get anal about issues, however on the proper aspect of the cardboard the place the letters are positioned on high of each other, it reads the phrases “IN HER A**”. The tantalizing Rousey Patch Auto card has gross sales eclipsing $1,000, though the set gives a extra inexpensive variation with a patch relic and no signature. Current gross sales of the non-autographed model can go for $500.
Abstract
Error playing cards have been a part of the buying and selling card interest because the starting. Over the previous 50 years, the excitement, controversy, and rarity round NSFW error playing cards have given collectors a novel — and quirky — lane to chase.
Nevertheless, because the interest has developed, extra buying and selling playing cards are being produced than ever earlier than and collectors have change into accustomed to error playing cards. Due to this, the development of amassing newly launched error playing cards and their values isn’t what it was once.
As somebody who appreciates the historical past of the interest and collects memorable playing cards that stand the take a look at of time, I crown Billy Ripken’s 1989 Fleer FF as the final word NSFW error card.
Have you ever thought-about including any of the playing cards on this record to your assortment? Are there any notable NFSW error playing cards that didn’t make the record? Tell us within the feedback under!
Associated
Trending Merchandise
